Sandro Tonali: Newcastle United Star Linked Again to Italian Gambling Probe

Newcastle United midfielder Sandro Tonali has been named in an extended investigation by Italian authorities into alleged illegal betting – but is unlikely to face further sanctions.

Italian prosecutors in Milan have expanded an existing investigation into illegal gambling activity involving professional footballers. Among those named are Newcastle United’s Sandro Tonali and Fiorentina’s Nicolo Fagioli. The evidence cited in this latest development stems from testimonies given by both players 18 months ago.

Fagioli, who served a seven-month ban after admitting to betting breaches, issued a public apology and claimed that Tonali had introduced him to the illicit platforms. Italian news outlets ANSA and AGI have since reported the involvement of other high-profile names, including Roma’s Leandro Paredes, Weston McKennie (formerly of Leeds United), and Angel Di Maria, the ex-Manchester United forward.

Despite the renewed scrutiny, sources close to Newcastle United suggest this is not a “new” investigation but an extension of a previously launched inquiry. Tonali, who received a 10-month suspension last year shortly after joining Newcastle for £55 million from AC Milan, is not expected to face additional footballing bans—though a financial penalty remains a possibility.

Tonali and Fagioli speak out

Nicolo Fagioli addressed the media storm in a heartfelt Instagram post:

“I made mistakes and I paid for them. And like anyone who makes a mistake and pays for it, I have every right to get back up… I was 19 when all this happened and I was overcome by a gambling addiction. I regret it, but life gave me a second opportunity and I want to take advantage of it, having already been punished for everything I deserved to be punished for.

I apologise to all of my teammates and friends who, because of my mistakes, are finding themselves involved or named. And I want to thank Fiorentina, Juventus, my friends and family, who never stopped supporting me during a tough time. Even if I definitely disappointed them.”

Tonali, now fully integrated into Eddie Howe’s squad, reflected on his past struggles in an interview with Sky Sports following his return to competitive football in August:

“Before the mistake, I had two lives, because I was very closed to myself and I never spoke with people, also in the training ground, also with the staff.

Now it’s totally different. Every day is different, especially with the staff and my teammates… Before these 10 months, before the last year, I don’t know. It’s a little bit different because I was another person. I was two different people in my life and in football. And now I am only one person, only one.”

Support from the Toon Army

Despite the controversy, Tonali has been embraced by Newcastle United fans and staff alike. His contributions have been vital this season, helping the club secure its first domestic trophy in 70 years and pushing for a Champions League place. The club’s unified support has been key to his rehabilitation, both on and off the pitch.

Site Opinion

It’s easy to be cynical when footballers fall from grace, but Tonali’s story illustrates a rare narrative of humility and growth. Newcastle United’s response—standing by their player in the face of scandal—says a lot about the culture Eddie Howe is fostering at the club. It’s not just about performances; it’s about people.

The broader issue here is the growing concern around gambling in sport. Young players, many barely out of their teens, are being pulled into an industry with serious addictive potential and far-reaching consequences. As this investigation unfolds, the football world must consider not just punishment, but prevention and care. If Tonali’s journey is anything to go by, redemption is possible—but it must be supported, not assumed.