Newcastle United vs Tottenham Prediction: Holders Eye Another Statement Win

Newcastle United return to St James’ Park tonight for a huge Carabao Cup showdown against Tottenham Hotspur as Eddie Howe’s side look to continue their defence of the trophy.

The Magpies lifted the League Cup last season and are targeting another deep run, but Spurs side arrive full of attacking flair and confidence after an impressive start to their campaign.

Form Guide and Key Battles

Newcastle United have been in solid form across competitions, showing the resilience needed to balance domestic and European fixtures. They enter this clash on the back of a dramatic weekend victory over Fulham, sealed by a late Bruno Guimarães goal, and have scored four times in each of their last two cup games.

Their performances at home continue to define them. St James’ Park under the lights has been an intimidating venue, and Newcastle’s only home defeats this season have come against Liverpool, Arsenal, and Barcelona. That form will provide confidence heading into this tie, especially after beating Tottenham Hotspur twice last season.

Up for the Carabao Cup! 🏆 pic.twitter.com/x3X6MHJafW

— Newcastle United (@NUFC) October 29, 2025

Spurs, meanwhile, are finding consistency under Thomas Frank. They sit third in the Premier League following a 3–0 away win at Everton and have looked sharp on the road. The attacking trio of Mohammed Kudus, Brennan Johnson, and Mathys Tel has the pace and movement to trouble any defence, but the visitors will travel without several key names. Yves Bissouma, Dejan Kulusevski, and Cristian Romero are all unavailable through injury or suspension.

Predicted Lineups and Match Outlook

Howe is expected to field a strong side, balancing rotation with experience. Nick Woltemade could once again lead the line after a strong start to life in England, with his aerial presence likely to be crucial against a makeshift Spurs defence. Behind him, Anthony Gordon and Harvey Barnes are both expected to start, providing width and penetration.

Tottenham are likely to rely on goalkeeper Timo Kinsky with a back four featuring Pedro Porro, Kevin Danso, Micky van de Ven, and Djed Spence. The midfield duo of João Palhinha and Rodrigo Bentancur will be tasked with keeping control, while Kudus and Johnson should provide their main attacking threat.

This fixture has consistently delivered goals. Each of the last nine competitive meetings between these sides has produced more than two, and both teams favour front-foot football that encourages open, attacking play.

Newcastle’s combination of energy, home advantage, and attacking rhythm may ultimately prove decisive. A narrow victory for the holders would maintain their impressive record at St James’ Park and underline their ambition to retain the trophy.

Predicted score: Newcastle United 3–2 Tottenham Hotspur